Opened 2 years ago

Closed 2 years ago

#2 closed defect (wontfix)

Salt and/or ester parent hazards are created even when Note title says 'Not applicable'

Reported by: Mike Dewhirst Owned by:
Priority: medium Version: 0.9.x
Keywords: parents hazards "not applicable" Cc:

Description

When the software detects that a chemical has salt and/or ester parents, those parental hazards must be considered in the categorisation - unless a note exists with title "Salt and/or ester parent hazards - Not applicable".

This all happens at once and the hazards are added at the same time as the note is created to document why those hazards were added.

Thereafter, if the (expert) user appends 'Not applicable' to the note title, the software does not remove the parental hazards.

The workaround is for the user to manually delete all unwanted hazards then resave to generate only the known hazards of the chemical. The 'Not applicable' in the note title then prevents the parental hazards being added.

The reason we need to automate this is so the test-harness for a categorisation depending on the 'Not applicable' tag, is completely correct.

Currently, it (obviously) omits the manual hazard deletion step.

Change History (2)

comment:1 by Mike Dewhirst, 2 years ago

As an interim measure there is now an FAQ entry in https://chemintro.com/faq#saltester detailing the workaround.

Last edited 2 years ago by Mike Dewhirst (previous) (diff)

comment:2 by Mike Dewhirst, 2 years ago

Resolution: wontfix
Status: newclosed

Because some parental hazards might remain and others might be non-appropriate depending on the particular chemistry, it is (probably) impossible to automate this process. It requires expert judgment and therefore this ticket is being closed with 'wontfix'.

The abovementioned interim measure is hereby (probably) permanent.

Any user with the 'Authority' role may reopen this ticket either directly or via support at chemintro.com

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.